Skip to main content
Ages 16–18 · First home savings

LISA vs ISA — which to use for your first-home deposit

The Lifetime ISA gives you a 25% government bonus on up to £4,000 a year — £1,000 free money a year if you use it for a first home or for retirement. Here's when it beats a normal ISA, and when it doesn't.

Age band
16–18+
Reading time
8–10 min read
Topic
Lifetime ISA for first homes
UK relevance
UK-wide
Tax year
2026/27
Last reviewed
2026-05-11

What this guide covers

Open a Lifetime ISA (LISA) between age 18 and 39. Save up to £4,000 a year. The government adds a 25% bonus (up to £1,000/yr). Use it for a first home up to £450,000 or after age 60. If you take it out for anything else, you pay a 25% withdrawal charge — which means you can lose some of your own money, not just the bonus.

The four ISA types in one paragraph each

Cash ISA. A bog-standard savings account where the interest is tax-free. Up to £20,000 a year total ISA allowance across all your ISAs. Money is available any time. Interest rates in 2026 are typically 4-5% on fixed-rate, 3-4% easy-access.

Stocks & Shares ISA. Same £20,000 cap, same tax wrapper. But the money is invested in shares, funds or bonds, so it can go up or down. Historically returns average roughly 5-7% a year after fees over long horizons, but can be -30% in a bad year and +30% in a good one.

Lifetime ISA. Open from age 18-39. £4,000/yr cap (counts against the £20k overall allowance). Government adds 25% bonus monthly. Two legitimate uses: first home (up to £450,000) or retirement at age 60+. Anything else triggers a 25% withdrawal charge that can leave you worse off than you started.

Innovative Finance ISA. Peer-to-peer lending wrapper. Higher rates, much higher risk, no FSCS protection. Most under-25s should skip this.

How the LISA bonus actually works

The government pays the 25% bonus directly into your LISA, normally within 4-9 weeks of each contribution.

Max contribution
£4,000 / yr
Max bonus
£1,000 / yr
Open age
18–39
Stop paying in at
Age 50

If you open a LISA at 18 and pay in £4,000 a year, by age 50 you've paid in £128,000 and received £32,000 in free bonuses. With investment growth on top, the LISA can comfortably reach £200-300k as a first-home or retirement pot.

Realistic version. Most teenagers can't put £4,000 a year aside. Even £20 a month earns the bonus — £240/yr in becomes £300/yr saved. Don't feel locked out because you can't max it.

The £450,000 cap — and why it bites in London

To use the LISA for a first home, the property has to cost £450,000 or less. That cap has been frozen since 2017, despite house-price inflation. In most of the UK it's plenty. In central London, large parts of the South East, Cambridge, Oxford, Edinburgh, Bristol and some commuter belts, average flats already exceed it.

If you complete on a property over £450k, you can't use the LISA for the deposit — and if you do withdraw, you pay the 25% withdrawal charge. So in 2026, students saving for first homes in expensive areas need a backup plan (a S&S ISA alongside the LISA, or splitting your saving).

The 25% withdrawal charge — the trap

If you take money out of a LISA for anything except a first home or retirement, the government takes back the bonus plus a penalty. The maths is sneaky.

You put in £1,000. Government adds £250. You have £1,250. You withdraw the £1,250 early — government takes 25% of the £1,250 = £312.50. You walk away with £937.50. You're down £62.50 of your own money.

Rule of thumb. Only put money in a LISA that you're confident you can leave in for a first home or for age 60. If you might need it for any other emergency, use a normal Cash or S&S ISA.

LISA vs S&S ISA: which to use first

If your goal is a first home within 2-3 years: Cash LISA. Bonus is huge, time horizon too short for stock-market risk.

If your goal is a first home in 5+ years: Stocks & Shares LISA. Long enough for share-market growth to outweigh short-term wobbles.

If your goal is to save for retirement: Pension first (employer match), then S&S LISA as a top-up. Pensions normally win on tax for retirement, but the LISA bonus + flexibility to use it as either home deposit or retirement makes it a decent second wrapper.

If you might need the money for anything except retirement or first home: S&S ISA, no LISA.

NCNational Curriculum links

Full mapping in the curriculum map.

Cite this guide
UK Tax Drag (2026). LISA vs ISA — which to use for your first-home deposit. Ages 16–18 deep guide. Available at: https://kids.uktaxdrag.co.uk/ages-16-18-lisa-vs-isa-for-first-home.html
Curriculum mapping: see UK Financial Education Curriculum Map (Version 1.0).
Not financial advice. This guide explains how the UK system works for educational purposes. Always check current rates and rules at gov.uk and consider talking to a qualified adviser before making real financial decisions, especially before age 18.